|
With his fourth novel, Black Swan Green,
David Mitchell has finally
given us what many novelists do with their first novel: a story that is
set in
the writer’s own home turf, or a place much like it, is rooted in
autobiography, and is somehow a summary of the writer’s life up until a
certain point. Black Swan Green chronicles one year in the life of
young Jason
Taylor, stammerer, aspiring poet, and middling-popular kid trying to
find his
way through the complex hierarchies of adolescent society, the
minefields of a
home where a marriage is slowly going off the rails, and a community
where
recent arrivals like him are still seen as urbanised interlopers.
There’s
nothing especially unusual about this story – the fact that Jason is
13-going-on-14, certainly 13 and three-fourths at some point, should
tell you
that this novel fits into the well-defined and populated subset of
coming-of-age novels.
What is unusual is that Mitchell, who dazzled
readers with his
ambitious structures and interweaving of disparate narrative voices and
generic
conventions in previous novels, such as Ghostwritten or the
Babushka-doll like
Cloud Atlas, should choose to tackle such a straightforward narrative
after his
previous virtuoso displays. It soon becomes clear, however, that
Mitchell has
not rejected his immense formal and stylistic ability and ambition in
this
novel – instead, he’s set them in a different key, a pastoral minor
as it were, to contrast with the grand symphonic ensemble flourishes of
his
previous work. His fascination with structure as a narrative device is
reflected in the fact that the chapters of this book each deal with
just one
month in Jason’s year of awakening. Each chapter deals with some
important events in that space of time, with the chapter titles
referring to a
key motif within, and nearly each chapter leaving loose ends that are
referred
back to in future chapters, with all the loops finally being closed in
a last
chapter that literally and figuratively revisits the territory of the
first.
His talent for finally nuanced narrative voices is on display here too
–
Jason’s own awareness and perception of the world around him slowly
evolves as the novel progresses, and Mitchell reflects this in his
first-person
narrative, subtly at times, and sometimes with a grand flourish, as in
a
chapter where Jason thrice visits the home of an eccentric Belgian lady
who
teaches him that poetry should not create beauty, but reflect truth.
Jason’s initial descriptions of her home are freighted with a
breathless
sense of exotica, and then the same settings are successively described
in
terms that are less aesthetically charged, but truer and therefore more
evocative. More subtly, a cousin whom Jason idolizes and tries to
emulate at
first, is eventually dismissed as ‘smarmy’. Mitchell uses the
plasticity of an adolescent’s consciousness to strike a variety of
notes,
from a Grimm Brothers like fairytale spookiness, through a sort of
magic-realist literary awakening to poignant, exquisitely observed
realism and
satire. Jason and his Shropshire
countryside
may define the confines of this narrative, but it is clear that both
contain
many worlds, as diverse as the kaleidoscopic settings of Mitchell’s
past
work.
Finally, all Mitchell’s novels have some
concrete link with each
other – a specific character who is, or is connected to, a character in
another of his books – that’s the case here, as well. In addition,
the song #9dream, the title of an earlier novel by Mitchell, is
strategically
inserted at a key moment in the narrative – Jason’s first kiss, as
a matter of fact.
Even though Black Swan Green isn’t as much of
a departure from
Mitchell’s previous work as it might seem at first, it still has to
sink or
swim on its own merits. It succeeds at this task. While Jason might
seem at
times more insightful than is common at his age, there are enough times
when he
is merely callow or trite as well, which seems about right for his age.
The
various characters he interacts with are equally well-realised and
believable,
and the novel reflects the year it is set in – 1982 – incredibly
well, with contemporary politics and pop culture often setting the
stage for
Jason’s personal experiences. This may not be the most technically
dazzling novel I’ve read by Mitchell, but it is as gripping, thoughtful
and moving as anything he’s written. Mitchell has shown he can strike
gold, or at least silver, in even the most played-out of literary
soils, and I
can’t wait to see where he chooses to delve next.
|